DrayTek UK Users' Community Forum
Help, Advice and Solutions from DrayTek Users
Duo MFA Draytek Integration
- gvrvm
- Topic Author
- Offline
- New Member
Less
More
- Posts: 3
- Thank you received: 0
03 Jul 2022 01:33 #101327
by gvrvm
Duo MFA Draytek Integration was created by gvrvm
Hi All,
Hoping someone can help with Duo MFA integration with any model of Draytek.
We have this working without issue with other manufacturers but we can get it working with a Draytek.
The set up is simple, users can already successfully connect using the Draytek Smart VPN Client, the Draytek router in turn authorises users via NPS on a Windows Server.
If we take NPS out of the equation and put the Duo Proxy in between the Draytek and Windows Server, using the Duo Proxy as the Radius Server for the Draytek to go through, everything works. Only while MFA is turned off.
Turn on MFA via Policies in the Duo portal and users can't successfully connect.
When trying to connect, users enter their credentials as usual, they then receive the Push notification as expected but before they have the opportunity to Approve the connection they receive an error from the Draytek VPN Client saying that their credentials are incorrect.
Given the speed that happens I suspect its a Radius Timeout issue, the one common setting not available on Draytek routers for some reason. That, or the Draytek is receiving something back it doesn't like.
Anyone here got Duo MFA successfully working using Draytek's native VPN?
Cheers,
GVR
Hoping someone can help with Duo MFA integration with any model of Draytek.
We have this working without issue with other manufacturers but we can get it working with a Draytek.
The set up is simple, users can already successfully connect using the Draytek Smart VPN Client, the Draytek router in turn authorises users via NPS on a Windows Server.
If we take NPS out of the equation and put the Duo Proxy in between the Draytek and Windows Server, using the Duo Proxy as the Radius Server for the Draytek to go through, everything works. Only while MFA is turned off.
Turn on MFA via Policies in the Duo portal and users can't successfully connect.
When trying to connect, users enter their credentials as usual, they then receive the Push notification as expected but before they have the opportunity to Approve the connection they receive an error from the Draytek VPN Client saying that their credentials are incorrect.
Given the speed that happens I suspect its a Radius Timeout issue, the one common setting not available on Draytek routers for some reason. That, or the Draytek is receiving something back it doesn't like.
Anyone here got Duo MFA successfully working using Draytek's native VPN?
Cheers,
GVR
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- scroucher
- Offline
- Junior Member
Less
More
- Posts: 47
- Thank you received: 0
20 Dec 2023 21:18 #103064
by scroucher
Steve
Replied by scroucher on topic Re: Duo MFA Draytek Integration
Did you ever get this working? I've set Duo as a Radius server with my 2862 as the client. The Duo proxy complains that no password has been passed on by the Vigor router.
Steve
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- gvrvm
- Topic Author
- Offline
- New Member
Less
More
- Posts: 3
- Thank you received: 0
22 Dec 2023 17:22 #103076
by gvrvm
Replied by gvrvm on topic Re: Duo MFA Draytek Integration
Afraid not.
I raised a support case with Draytek.
I went around in circles with them as I dont thing the Draytek support person ultimately understood the problem.
I believe the lack of radius server timeout settings, common on other routers, is ultimately the problem.
Without that, the Draytek appears to immediately close the connection before allowing credentials to be passed through in time.
In the end we abandoned using Draytek VPN and for those customers with Servers, used Windows VPN SSTP and Routing & Remote Access and/or Network Policy roles.
A pain I know, if you have a lot of people, but far easier.
I raised a support case with Draytek.
I went around in circles with them as I dont thing the Draytek support person ultimately understood the problem.
I believe the lack of radius server timeout settings, common on other routers, is ultimately the problem.
Without that, the Draytek appears to immediately close the connection before allowing credentials to be passed through in time.
In the end we abandoned using Draytek VPN and for those customers with Servers, used Windows VPN SSTP and Routing & Remote Access and/or Network Policy roles.
A pain I know, if you have a lot of people, but far easier.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- scroucher
- Offline
- Junior Member
Less
More
- Posts: 47
- Thank you received: 0
25 Dec 2023 09:22 #103087
by scroucher
Steve
Replied by scroucher on topic Re: Duo MFA Draytek Integration
Looking at wireshark logs, it looks to me as if the Vigor doesn't send a password in the initial RADIUS message but also doesn't correctly handle the subsequent password challenge.
Steve
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- gvrvm
- Topic Author
- Offline
- New Member
Less
More
- Posts: 3
- Thank you received: 0
02 Jan 2024 20:55 #103102
by gvrvm
Replied by gvrvm on topic Re: Duo MFA Draytek Integration
The issue is definetly with the Draytek, of that I have no doubt.
We work with a multitude of router/firewall vendors, Draytek currently are the only manufacture we've been unable to make Duo work with (unfortunately).
We work with a multitude of router/firewall vendors, Draytek currently are the only manufacture we've been unable to make Duo work with (unfortunately).
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
Moderators: Sami
Copyright © 2024 DrayTek